At the Vermont Academy College Counseling Office, we strive to help our students find the colleges that match their abilities and interests and where they can be successful. From the moment they join our tight-knit community, we work closely with our students to determine the right balance of academic challenge and extracurricular activity to serve them well on the road ahead. Finding the right college fit is an important journey in self-awareness and one that asks our students to seek direction. We are committed to providing them with the expertise, guidelines, and resources to make that process run both smoothly and effectively. If you are interested in the resources our college preparatory school offers or if you'd like to meet with a member of our team, we encourage you to contact us today!
The College Counseling Process by Each Grade Level
Take the most rigorous courses you can reasonably manage
Maintain good grades
Ensure that you are signed up for the ACT or SAT tests in the spring. You may want to take them again in the fall of your senior year. Prepare for the standardized tests; look for tutoring as needed
Think about the clubs, activities and work experience you have had and also what you need to add to your profile to be a stronger college candidate
Attend College Seminar classes and meet with your college counselor
Use available resources to develop college lists and to learn more about the schools on your list. Rank the features of colleges that are most important to you
Narrow your list of colleges of interest and determine what it takes to be accepted. Your list should contain 8-12 colleges
Research financial aid options as needed
Use vacation times to visit schools – register online for info sessions and tours
Review your ACT/SAT test scores when they arrive to see areas where you might want to improve
Ask two of your teachers for letters of recommendation.
Add any new awards or honors to your file
Create a common application account Take AP exams (if applicable)
SUMMER
Explore summer activities related to your career goals. If possible, you may also want to explore potential internships
Participate in an academic enrichment or leadership program, camp, college, etc
If you will be looking for accommodations in college, most will require current (within three years) cognitive and achievement testing for LD/ADHD accommodations; take these over the summer
The Vermont Academy College Counseling team strives to create an explorative space that supports students through their college application process and beyond. Our self-discovery and growth oriented programming is designed to support students and families to make healthy and confident decisions regarding their futures as they are simultaneously developing healthy excellence on our campus. Below is a sampling of our diversified 100% college acceptance rate list.
Albany College of Pharmacy and Health Sciences Albertus Magnus College Alderson Broaddus University American International College American University Amherst College Anna Maria College (2) Arizona State University- Tempe (2) Assumption University Ave Maria University Bates College Baylor University Bennington College Bentley University (3) Bishop's University Boston College (2) Boston University (6) Brandeis University Bryant University Bryn Mawr College California Polytechnic State University Case Western Reserve University Central Connecticut State University Champlain College Chatham University Clark University (4) Clarkson University Colby-Sawyer College Colgate University Colorado Mesa University Colorado School of Mines Colorado State University (2) Concordia University (7) Connecticut College Cornell College Curry College Dartmouth College (2) Dean College Denison University DigiPen Institute of Technology Dominican University Drexel University Elmhurst University Elmira College Elon University (2) Emerson College (2) Endicott College (2) Erskine College Fitchburg State University (2) Florida Gulf Coast University Fordham University (2) Franklin Pierce University George Mason University Georgetown University Gettysburg College Goucher College Greenville Technical College Hamilton College (2) Harcum College Hartwick College Haverford College HEC Montreal High Point University (2) Hobart and William Smith Colleges (4) Hofstra University Husson University (3) IE University - Madrid Instituto Tecnológico y de Estudios Superiores de Monterrey Iowa Western Community College Ithaca College Jacksonville University Johnson & Wales University, Providence Keene State College (2) Lafayette College Lake Forest College Lebanon Valley College (2) Lees-McRae College (2) Lehigh University (2) Lesley University (2) Lewis & Clark College Liberty University Long Island University - Brooklyn Loyola Marymount University Loyola University Chicago Lycoming College Lynn University Manhattanville University (3) Marist University Massachusetts College of Liberal Arts McPherson College (2) Merrimack College (4) Mid-America Christian University
Millersville University of Pennsylvania Nazareth University (2) New England College (2) New Jersey Institute of Technology New York University (2) Northeastern University (3) Norwich University (4) Pace University (2) Palm Beach Atlantic University Paul Smith's College Plymouth State University (3) Pratt Institute Providence College (2) Purdue University Queen's University Quinnipiac University (3) Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute (3) Rochester Institute of Technology Roger Williams University (2) Royal Military College of Canada Sacred Heart University Saint Anselm College Saint Joseph’s College of Maine Saint Michael's College (9) Santa Clara University Salem State University Salisbury University Salve Regina University (3) Siena University Sierra Nevada University Smith College Southern New Hampshire University Springfield College (2) State University of New York College of Technology at Delhi St. Catherine University St. Cloud State University St. Lawrence University (2) SUNY Fredonia SUNY Oswego SUNY Cortland Stevenson University Stony Brook University (2) Suffolk University (2) Syracuse University (4) Texas Christian University The University of Alabama (2) The University of Kansas The University of Tampa The University of Utah (3) The University of West Florida Temple University Towson University Trinity College (6) Trinity University Tufts University Tulane University (2) Union College (3) United States Military Academy University of Bridgeport University of California, Santa Cruz University of Central Florida (2) University of Colorado Boulder University of Connecticut University of Denver (3) University of Florida University of Hartford (2) University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign University of Maine (3) University of Saint Joseph UMASS - Amherst (5) UMASS – Boston University of Maryland – Baltimore County University of New England (3) University of New Hampshire (6) University of New Haven University of Rhode Island (3) University of the District of Columbia University of Toronto (2) University of Vermont (16) Universidad Iberoamericano Utica University (2) Vassar College (4) Vermont State University (8) Virginia Tech Virginia Military Institute Washington University in St. Louis Wentworth Institute of Technology Western Washington University Westminster University Wheaton College (2) Worcester Polytechnic Institute (4)
Caitlin Holton joined Vermont Academy in 2014 in the Student Life office with a background in business. As an alumna of the Class of 1996, and parent of Wildcats Hannah ’26 and Sophie ’28, Caitlin has a longstanding relationship with Vermont Academy and has assumed a variety of leadership roles on campus including Assistant Dean of Student Life, Class Dean of various grade levels, advisor, Equestrian coach, affiliate dorm parent, and is currently in the role of Associate Director of College Counseling. Caitlin believes in developing supportive relationships with her students and is passionate about working with them to achieve their goals and personal and academic growth.
Caitlin obtained her Bachelor of Arts degree from the University of Vermont where she took a special interest in psychology, sociology, relational behaviors, and childhood development. She lives off campus in Dummerston, VT. When she is not on campus, Caitlin enjoys horseback riding, snowboarding, traveling, and spending time with her family.
Connor Merrill '11
College Counselor / Head Coach Boys Prep Basketball
Connor rejoined the Vermont Academy community in 2026 as Head Prep Basketball Coach and College Counselor.
A 2011 graduate of Vermont Academy, Connor understands firsthand the transformative power of this community. As a student, he experienced the blend of challenge, belonging, mentorship, and growth that defines the VA experience. After graduating, he returned to campus in 2015 as an assistant coach, helping lead Vermont Academy to the 2016 NEPSAC Class AA Championship and contributing to one of the most memorable chapters in our basketball program’s history.
Connor returns to Vermont Academy after building an exceptional career in both independent school and collegiate athletics. Most recently, as Head Coach at Deerfield Academy, he led one of the most impressive program turnarounds in recent NEPSAC history. In just four years, he guided Deerfield to its most successful basketball season ever, earning the program’s first NEPSAC Class A postseason berth, a #3 seed, and a semifinal appearance. For his leadership, Connor was named the 2026 NEPSAC Class A Coach of the Year.
Prior to Deerfield, Connor coached at both Middlebury College and Springfield College, helping those programs reach three NCAA Tournaments, including a Final Four run in 2018.
Connor lives Alumni Dorm with his wife, Christa, and their golden retriever, Doug.
Dustin Walsh
College Counselor / Head Coach Boys' Varsity Hockey
Dustin joined Vermont Academy in the fall of 2025 as the Head Coach of Boys’ Varsity Hockey and an Assistant College Counselor. He brings to VA a wealth of experience working with student athletes at all levels. While at Seacoast Performance Academy (SPA) he worked as a coach, on-ice skills coach, video analysis coach, scheduler, and dorm parent. Prior to SPA, he spent four years as an assistant hockey coach at Plymouth State University (NH) where the team earned two league championships. Dustin graduated from the University of New England with a Bachelor's Degree in Communications while also playing on the hockey team all four years.
He loves working with high school student-athletes and helping them achieve their goals. Vermont Academy has proven to be made up of like-minded people that want what's best for their students and he is thrilled to be part of this legacy.
Dustin lives on campus in Alumni Dorm. He really enjoys staying active and fills most of his free time with sports and outdoor pursuits. Golf is one of his favorite summer activities. He also enjoys watching sports, especially live games, and keeping up with his favorite teams.